Question for Hick

By: the909trojan



Genuine question, I'm not baiting you here. I respect and understand your position as a strict interpreter of the constitution, going strictly by the letters written. I don't always agree with that but I respect it.

 

So, here's the scenario. A 17 year old female encourages and in fact urges her boyfriend to kill himself. He does, inhaling carbon monoxide. She is charged with manslaughter, and her defense is that her texts are covered under the first ammendment. I disagree with her defense, as did the court today.

 

How say you sir, agree or disagree? Do first ammendment rights allow somebody to tell anther person to kill himself with no repercussions? 

Post Please Log in OR Register for an account before posting.