I still think Gibson is 1.
Is Freddie’s slam 2? Now that they won the series it can be considered. If they don’t then it’s just a great moment. But given that they also won this in 5 like in 1988. Also on the road. I think there are many parallels.
I imagine my dad would argue for 1955 after all those Yankee losses and the great 55 team. Probably can argue for the two 1960s pitching dominated teams.
But as we look to single moments and understand they have to be in the context of something great. Like a championship?
I’m thinking these are 1-2. And I saw them both as they happened. On tv lol
you might enjoy this.