Uo just kept the top recruits who beat him out. If you can recruit that much talent then this works. Oregon is doing that and gets to keep that top talent for 3-5 years. The ones that stay. I like their approach better than USCs frankly
So it appears to me that this is the game now. This is a kid who has 4 star talent. Redshirted and didn’t play a lot as a rd shirt frosh.
not long ago we would consider this normal. He would now begin his upward ascent to starter. Contributor. Then possibly star.
now he is upset that he couldn’t jump start those first couple years. And decides to take his trajectory to a new locale.
meanwhile oregon recruits hs 5 stars. Keeps those who survive and becomes a feeding ground for other peograms to continue the development of kids who didn’t show out early.
the result will be those that do leave oregon after 3 years and those that don’t will end up at other places and play 4-5.
im not judging. I’m mentally working through the sense of this.
so if you’re usc or ucla you have a choice. Recruit a top class of hs kids knowing you’re going to keep whoever pans out and lose the rest. Or go get those kids who are more proven and looking for greener pastures. Like recruiting a smaller and perhaps more elite class of hs kids. Assuming a greater percentage of those elite ones will stick around with PT and fill in the rest w transfers who are proven .
Does that sound like What we are seeing?
im trying to make sense of this crazy world we now live in
while true for the most part. There were a few they didn’t want to transfer: McGee, Thornton, Flowe, Mataveo. All were going to get significant playing time. 2nd string at worse.
First, the government (state or federal, it doesn't matter which) will declare that in the NIL Era the players are employees of the university.
Then, players' unions and a series of CBAs. I see local or regional unions, not a national union. What will the players -- strike that -- what will their representatives demand? Revenue sharing. A week off before any big game (the Notre Dame rule) or a game against the Citadel after Veterans' Day (the SEC rule). No games starting after 7:00 local time. First-class travel. Wolfgang Puck traning tables.
I think the used car approach can be valuable. I've only bought one new car in my life and learned my lesson; why lose five grand driving the fucker off the lot? I don't buy pieces of shit, I buy nice cars, and there's nothing wrong with a used car if you know what you're doing, which I do.
So it is with portal guys -- a lot of them anyway. Maybe not with this Williams kid, who hasn't really shown what he can do, so they're probably taking him on potential. But look at so many other portal transfers who have panned out. And I'm not just talking about the Caleb Williams of the world, those guys are different and it's a different situation (tied to a coach, etc.). At UCLA, take a guy like Jake Bobo, for instance. He may have played for Duke, which isn't a killer program. But it's still ACC, and they still play FBS football, and sometimes they're good. So, it was easy for Chip to see that this guy had skills that enabled him to get open, catch the rock, and get upfield. Chip knew that in his offense this guy, while not a burner, was going to move the chains. Bottom line: this guy had already played a lot of FBS football, so the learning curve was minimal (just learn the new offense), and he didn't have to get used to being in college, etc. That is far more valuable than most high school kids. True, if you can get the burners and the freaks out of high school, by all means do it. But most of those guys don't go to UCLA, just the way it is. And that was even before Chip.
The trouble with the portal is COMPETITION, same as high school. The good ones go fast, but the return can be much greater if you land the right ones. If you don't get the portal guys you need, you better have high school kids you are developing. It can't be either or, it has to be both. That's where Chip needs to improve, and fast.
“Has a quick first step and plays with leverage, using his length to get to the ball carrier and quarterback. Can get caught overpursuing but shows ability to get to the play quickly. Good at dipping and ripping, showing a variety of moves but also using his strength and physicality overpower blockers. Plays with consistency and shows a good motor and routinely makes impact plays. Projects as a Power 5 starter and third day NFL pick.”
Bruins are quietly building a defense.
Dead wood per LA Duck. To everyone else, seems like a good get!
So it appears to me that this is the game now. This is a kid who has 4 star talent. Redshirted and didn’t play a lot as a rd shirt frosh.
not long ago we would consider this normal. He would now begin his upward ascent to starter. Contributor. Then possibly star.
now he is upset that he couldn’t jump start those first couple years. And decides to take his trajectory to a new locale.
meanwhile oregon recruits hs 5 stars. Keeps those who survive and becomes a feeding ground for other peograms to continue the development of kids who didn’t show out early.
the result will be those that do leave oregon after 3 years and those that don’t will end up at other places and play 4-5.
im not judging. I’m mentally working through the sense of this.
so if you’re usc or ucla you have a choice. Recruit a top class of hs kids knowing you’re going to keep whoever pans out and lose the rest. Or go get those kids who are more proven and looking for greener pastures. Like recruiting a smaller and perhaps more elite class of hs kids. Assuming a greater percentage of those elite ones will stick around with PT and fill in the rest w transfers who are proven .
Does that sound like What we are seeing?
im trying to make sense of this crazy world we now live in
Brandon Huffman’s evaluation of KW out of HS:
“Has a quick first step and plays with leverage, using his length to get to the ball carrier and quarterback. Can get caught overpursuing but shows ability to get to the play quickly. Good at dipping and ripping, showing a variety of moves but also using his strength and physicality overpower blockers. Plays with consistency and shows a good motor and routinely makes impact plays. Projects as a Power 5 starter and third day NFL pick.”